Atc pilot vs grigri. Save yourself the trouble.

Atc pilot vs grigri You may never get a solid answer regarding Grigri vs. So, I do agree that anything that’s cheaper, especially by five times, is going to be more popular. Two popular options, the Grigri and the ATC, have become mainstays in the climbing […] Black Diamond ATC Guide best practices vs. The devices are very similar in operation. This is because the Grigri is auto-blocking while an ATC belayed from a harness is not. Maybe the ATC Pilot is a little more intuitive to learn because it has the pistol grip. About Us. We found the . We have been climbing for about 2 years so we are relative newbies – we are mainly focused on outdoor sport climbing. There are advantages and disadvantages to using the two belaying devices. seminar where the main instructor indicated that he is comfortable using the ATC in guide-mode without always having a hand on the brake-side of the rope because when used that way, it is an "auto-locking device. The pilot is about $40, the Grigri is like $100. It’s different than an atc but easy to learn and the assisted breaking is nice. If cost is keeping you from getting a grigri then the atc is Jan 3, 2024 · GriGri vs ATC: The Pros & Cons. i don’t know if i’d ever use anything else now although i haven’t tried anything other than grigri, atc, and now pilot. " Aug 24, 2018 · The Smart 2. The ATC, on the other hand, cannot arrest a fall if the belayer releases the rope. Dec 22, 2022 · With only one rope, added safety can be achieved by incorporating an assisted braking tube-style device, like the Black Diamond Pilot, without sacrificing a smooth belay. I tried lead belaying with both the Grigri and the ATC pilot. Once someone is proficient with both an ATC and a GriGri2, I think the case is difficult to make that the ATC is any safer. As a gear nerd it was fun to try but it’s not the device to buy. I prefer the Edelrid Mega Jul because it's a little more versatile, but the ATC Pilot is pretty similar and certainly a great choice for single pitch belays. A crucial component of climbing safety lies in the belay device. but i think at the end of the day, use whatever you Nov 18, 2019 · These devices were the; Edelrid Mega Jul, Black Diamond ATC Pilot, Mammut Smart and we also tried the auto-locking Beal Birdie. GriGri2 pays out slack very easily when you get the hand positioning right, makes the falls/hanging a lot more comfortable (especially when the belayer is off the ground), prevents rope slip when people are hanging, and lowers very smoothly. We currently use a Black Diamond ATC Guide, so we are comfortable with tubular devices. I've been eyeing a grigri recently as holding tight on the ATC for braking when my lead partners are taking rest starts to wear on my hands during the 3 hour sessions. You’re not at a disadvantage per se. ATC: Safety Consideration. Final Thoughts. When the rope is weighted the angle of the device changes, locking the rope down, though, as we mentioned above, you still need to keep your brake hand on the rope. My ATC has gotten about 5 years of good use and is starting seem like it might be time put it away except for some rappelling. Both these devices can be used for multipitch climbing. The GriGri and the ATC climbing device have the same aim: to keep the climber safe. When I teach people to belay I always have them learn on an ATC as I’ve seen too many climbers depending on the assisted braking of other devices, leading them to do unsafe things like take their hands off the brake strand without tying off the belay. 5 mm range. when used correctly an ATC is a time-tested, effective device. com Aug 6, 2021 · GriGri vs. ATC and which is objectively better. Both the GriGri and the ATC have strengths and weaknesses, and an experienced climber should be able to use them nearly interchangeably. Feb 21, 2020 · The Black Diamond ATC Pilot is a “geometry assisted” belay device for ropes in the 8. If a belayer lets go of the brake strand during a fall, the Grigri will still lock up and catch the climber. That said, it stays at home because the grigri can do the same thing (better) and more. A GriGri can generally handle a top belay just as efficiently as an ATC-Guide, and simul-rapping is an option when necessary. However, their mechanisms and features vary from one another, while some climbers prefer the GriGri and others the ATC. I used the pilot a lot when I first got it. The pilot is easier to learn how to use especially if you learned to climb with the ATC. 0 beats out the Black Diamond ATC Pilot in all categories except for the package size on the harness, and would be my recommended choice for any climber looking for an added layer of security in case of an injury of the belayer at a lower weight and price point than a grigri. The belay device serves as a friction-enhancing tool that assists climbers in controlling the rope during ascent and descent. GriGri is the easier to use of the two. 7 to 10. Some climbers Jun 6, 2025 · GriGri vs. GriGri offers a great safety solution, but the ATC (absolute trust in the device) is a more comprehensive solution. It functions similar to tube-style belay devices but offers superior bite when the leader falls or hangs for a while on the rope. GriGri, specifically for top-belay I recently attended a two day trad. ATC: Which Is Best for Multipitch Climbing? The Black Diamond ATC set up on multipitch belay on the Casual Route on Longs Peak. It's easier to feed slack through than the Grigri. Save yourself the trouble. But rest assured that the two pieces of equipment have been proven to protect and make the climbers safe . The ATC is suitable for all outdoor activities and is not only ideal for climbers. If you are not sure which one is best for you, here are some pros and cons of both belaying devices. GriGri is a much more comfortable device and has an adjustable mount. 0 is Mammut’s assisted belay device. Jun 16, 2018 · From my testing, the Mammut Smart 2. Once you get the hang of it, ATC pilot wins in every category. ” The Verdict. i switched from atc to atc pilot because of a she moves mountains trip where they required (and provided) pilots specifically and i loved how similar it was to the atc. However, the Grigri is overall a safer belay device. Aug 3, 2023 · Reading Time: 4 minutesUnveiling the Differences When it comes to climbing, safety is paramount. Petzl GriGri See full list on outdoorgearlab. Mar 2, 2023 · Comparing GriGri vs Atc gives you so much information, but the two belaying devices differ in functionalities and features. Dec 13, 2023 · I bought an ATC first because the GriGri was expensive and it looked scary. cxi cceqb wbhgvo mbbbzh vlmczb yek ibbcour pfk rfcjsx vnewl